A free way in, or a lower paid plan. Here is what each one buys.
AthenaHQ alternativeAthena alternativeAI visibility tool comparisonAI search ranking tracker
AthenaHQ is a San Francisco AI search platform with a free plan, a $295 a month Starter that reads 11 AI models, and an Enterprise plan by quote. SKYA's paid plans start lower, at $49 a month for 4 AI platforms on Spotlight and $79 a month for 5 on Agency Starter, and include a Hallucination Audit on every plan and one-click technical fixes on WordPress on Brand and every agency plan.
Athena gives you a free start and more AI models on its first paid plan. SKYA costs less once you pay, and installs the technical fixes it finds on Brand and every agency plan.
AthenaHQ's position: San Francisco AI search platform. A free Essential plan with $25 of credit; Starter at $295 a month with 3,600 credits and 11 AI models; Enterprise by quote with SSO, discrepancy detection and 60+ countries and languages. SOC 2 Type 2.

| Capability | SKYA | AthenaHQ |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest paid plan | $49 a month (Spotlight: 1 project, 20 tracked prompts on 4 AI platforms); agencies from $79 (Agency Starter: 2 clients, 30 tracked prompts on 5 AI platforms) | $295 per month (Starter: 11 AI models, 3,600 credits) |
| Free option | 7-day free trial, no credit card | Free Essential plan with $25 of credit (300 credits) |
| AI platforms tracked | Up to 5 in a plan: 4 AI platforms on Spotlight and Brand, 5 on every agency plan. ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews on every plan; Perplexity on Spotlight, Brand and Agency Starter; Grok on every agency plan; Copilot on Agency Pro; DeepSeek on Agency Growth. No plan reads Google AI Mode, Claude or Meta AI today. More AI platforms are coming soon as add-ons. | Athena: 5 on the free plan; 11 models on Starter, including Claude, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI and Mistral |
| Specialist agents | Hallucination Audit, Brand Sentiment and Keyword Gap Analysis on every plan at 1 credit a run, and On-Page Audit with the SEO module, on top of AI Visibility and Competitors as core features with their own menus | The Athena AI agent and a content optimization agent |
| Hallucination audit | On every plan, 1 credit a run (four credits for a deep audit), each claim checked against your own facts | Discrepancy detection listed on Enterprise |
| Competitors' intelligence | Rivals detected for you and tracked in AI answers on every plan (3 on Spotlight and Agency Starter, 5 on Brand, Agency Growth and Agency Pro, a brand or client), with the plan to beat them; their Google Top 100 keywords with the SEO module | Competitor insights in AI answers; classic search rankings not listed |
| Client-ready reports | Reports library, custom reports, PDF and Word exports with your logo, and share links that open with no login, on every plan; a client portal with your logo and free client seats on every agency plan | CSV export; BI tool integration on Enterprise |
| Publish drafts and fixes to your site | On Brand and every agency plan: one-click install on WordPress, head fixes through the SKYA apps for Shopify and Webflow, drafts into all three and eight headless stacks, seven of them in beta; on Spotlight, a pack coming soon | Publishes AEO content to Shopify; on-page and off-page actions |
| Prompt volume in your market, ICP and intent filters | Search demand scored 1 to 5 per tracked prompt, in the country you track, with persona and intent filters | Not listed on their feature page |
| Citation freshness and hidden sub-queries | Cited pages dated; the searches behind each answer recorded | Not listed on their feature page |
| Topic clusters and prompt tags | Topic clusters with suggested topics, and intent, buyer stage, persona and branded or comparison tags on every prompt | Unlimited topics, and persona targeting on Enterprise; intent and a buyer stage not listed (checked 15 October 2026) |
| AI crawler visits and AI referrals | AI crawler visits by page, on every plan, from your Cloudflare, the SKYA Helper for WordPress, a webhook with snippets for Vercel, Akamai and your own server, or a log upload (CloudFront and Google Cloud CDN included), plus an AI referral snippet; for any other host, SKYA Edge at $15 a project a month | AI crawler access managed through a smart robots.txt and llms.txt; crawler visits not listed (checked 15 October 2026) |
| Ads in AI answers | SKYA reports an ad when a ChatGPT answer carries one, with the prompt and who advertises. None has been seen in recent readings. | Not listed on their pricing page (checked 15 October 2026) |
| Honesty rules | Refund when nothing measured; scores withheld below the evidence floor | Not listed on their feature page |
| Meta Ads | Included on Brand, Agency Growth and Agency Pro, and $19 a brand or client a month on Spotlight and Agency Starter: creative lab, fatigue read, fixes with copy and image briefs | Not listed on their feature page |
| Google Reviews | Free on every plan: request links, QR codes, private feedback, what AI platforms say about your reputation | Not listed on their feature page |
| Reddit Visibility | Included on every plan: cited threads, who is named, the gaps | Not listed on their feature page |
| AI Shopping (AI shopping shelf) | Included on Brand, Agency Growth and Agency Pro, and from $29 a month on Spotlight and Agency Starter: your products in AI shopping answers, SKU by SKU, from your product catalogue | ChatGPT Shopping tracking |
| Seats | Unlimited on every plan | Unlimited members, the free plan included |
A tick marks the side that leads on that row. No tick means the two are even, or not directly comparable. Athena facts checked on 25 September 2026 against athenahq.ai/pricing and athenahq.ai. A cell that carries its own date was read again on that date.
An honest, feature-level breakdown of both platforms across the pillars that actually move the needle for answer engine optimization.
SKYA's paid plans start at $49 a month on Spotlight, and Spotlight, Brand, Agency Starter and Agency Growth all cost less than Athena's first paid plan, Starter, at $295 a month.
Athena's Essential plan is free, with $25 of credit, and does not end after 7 days. SKYA offers a 7-day free trial with no credit card, then a paid plan.
Athena's Starter reads 11 AI models, including Meta AI and Mistral. No SKYA plan reads Mistral, Google AI Mode, Claude or Meta AI today; SKYA's plans read 4 AI platforms on Spotlight and Brand, 5 on every agency plan.
On Brand and every agency plan, SKYA installs schema, meta tags, sitemap, robots and llms.txt on WordPress in one click and drafts into eight headless stacks, seven of them in beta. Athena lists on-page and off-page actions and a Shopify integration that publishes AEO content. Both reach your site; they reach it in different ways.
SKYA's Hallucination Audit asks the AI assistants on your plan a 38-prompt library, checks each claim against your own facts, and hands you the correction for every one that is false. It is on every SKYA plan, at 1 credit a run. Athena lists discrepancy detection on its Enterprise plan.
Every SKYA finding ends in something you can ship. The nine readiness checks each generate their fix on every plan. On Brand and every agency plan, schema, meta tags, sitemap, robots and llms.txt install on WordPress in one click; Shopify takes titles and descriptions for pages, products and collections, and schema, through the SKYA app, and Webflow takes your home page title, meta description and Open Graph after you approve them, live when you publish there; and any draft the Content Engine or the action plan writes carries a Publish to site button that creates an unpublished post or page in your own editor, on WordPress, Shopify, Webflow and Framer, and in beta on Ghost, Strapi, Directus, Payload, Sanity, Drupal and Adobe Experience Manager. Athena: publishes aeo content to shopify; on-page and off-page actions.
A SKYA audit that measured nothing is marked failed and refunds its credit; a reputation dimension without enough independent sources says Not scored instead of printing a number; every hallucination finding is checked against your own facts before it is called false; and the Reddit and citation counts are stored answers, never a rank. That is the difference between a dashboard you can put in front of a client and one you have to explain.
Meta Ads is included on Brand, Agency Growth and Agency Pro, and $19 a brand or client a month on Spotlight and Agency Starter. Reddit Visibility (the threads AI cites and where a rival is named instead of you) is included on every plan, AI Shopping (your products inside AI shopping answers) is included on Brand, Agency Growth and Agency Pro, and from $29 a month on Spotlight and Agency Starter, and Google Reviews (request links, QR codes, private feedback from unhappy customers, what AI platforms say about your reputation) is free on every plan. Athena: partial coverage, see the table above.
Spotlight at $49 a month, and Brand, for 2 brands, at $179 a month, both below Athena's first paid plan.
AI visibility and competitor tracking, then audits from measurement to fix.
Ship the recommended change without waiting on engineering, on Brand and every agency plan. Seven of the eight headless stacks are in beta.
Nothing SKYA generates stays trapped in the tool. Copy it, or, on Brand and every agency plan, send it to your site as a draft and finish it in the editor you already use.
Visibility, fixes, content, ads, reviews and Reddit for every client, with seats and roles, a project switcher on every page, dated client-ready reports, and add-on products you can resell.
For brands, Spotlight $49/mo (1 project, 20 tracked prompts on 4 AI platforms) and Brand $179/mo (2 brands, 100 tracked prompts on 4 AI platforms); Multi-brand and Enterprise by quote. For agencies, Agency Starter $79/mo (2 clients, 30 tracked prompts on 5 AI platforms), Agency Growth $245/mo (4 clients, 120 tracked prompts on 5 AI platforms) and Agency Pro $489/mo (10 projects, 270 tracked prompts on 5 AI platforms), and more clients at $29 a client a month on Agency Starter, $37 on Agency Growth and $34 on Agency Pro. Annual billing is ten months for twelve, and prices exclude tax. 7-day free trial for brands and agencies, no credit card.
Essential free with $25 of credit. Starter $295 a month, 17% off annually, with 3,600 credits. Enterprise by quote.
Athena is cheaper to try, with a free plan. SKYA is cheaper to pay for, from $49 a month.
Export tracked prompts and brand terms from AthenaHQ.
Start the SKYA 7-day trial and enter your domain.
Import prompts. Auto-discovery expands to 4 intent layers.
Let SKYA read your prompts across the AI platforms on your plan.
Invite team seats and, on Brand and every agency plan, enable Fix Now on your CMS.
Free 7-day trial. No credit card required. Up to 5 AI platforms in a plan, with competitor intelligence and hallucination audits on every plan, and fixes that reach your site once you approve them on Brand and every agency plan. The first answers land within minutes of setup, and every prompt is read daily on each AI platform in your plan.